At a pivotal moment in the Purim story, Mordechai asks Queen Esther to appeal to King Achashverosh to annul Haman’s genocidal decree. Esther hesitates, because to approach the King without being summoned was an offense punishable by death.

Mordechai’s response is striking. He makes no attempt to impress on her how important it was for her to take action at this moment. There’s no plea for her to disregard protocol in order to save the entire Jewish people. Instead he says, “If you stay silent at this time, relief and deliverance will come to the Jews from somewhere else, and you and your father’s house will perish. And who knows, perhaps the reason you became queen was [to act] at this time (Esther 4:14).”

Esther was merely a pawn in G-d’s plan to save the Jewish people. She was being called on to act on their behalf, but, Mordechai says, G-d will save the Jewish people from the decree even without her. Whether she heeds the call is her choice, and the loss is only hers if she declines.

When we find ourselves in a bind, when we see the escape routes are limited or none, we may naturally want to put all our hopes in one solution — or give up all hope when we see no option. We learn from Mordechai to remember that there is nothing G-d cannot do. (Based on Sefer Otzros HaTorah)

When Mordechai heard of Haman’s decree, his immediate reaction was to go out into the streets of Shushan and call the people to prayer. If we can still pray, there is still hope. The fact that a Jewish woman, his own cousin, was placed in such an influential position did not impress him — for he was confident the Jewish people would be saved through prayer, with or without Queen Esther. “Who can we rely upon? On our Father in Heaven – Avinu Shebashamayim!” (Mishna Sotah 9:15)


  1. Thank you rabbi for such a right comment and place the emphasis exactly on the basic truth, honouring Hashem, Who, of course was ( and still is) and always will be in full control. Even today when the world turns against the Jews and we call it anti semitism. He is calling His people back to the Land and who does not want to listen, reaps the consequences. Did He not send the heathen nations to invade Israel, so that they would again pray, turn from their wicked ways and He would deliver them? Nothing has changed. His principles are still the very same.
    I will not fight anti-semitism, but say Tehillim that we will return to Him and Torah and Israel, HIS LAND FOR HIS CHOSEN. Tehillim 122:6,7. G-d bless you and yours.
    Ruth Nussbaum

  2. Thank you! Beautiful dvar Torah with an inspiring and uplifting message that can be applied in our daily lives.

  3. Prayer without action is not enough…

    • You’re right – it’s not enough, and that’s why Mordechai had Esther take action. However, action does not bring the results. Ultimately G-d listening to our prayers, or acting out of His own kindness, is what makes it all happen.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *